Should I Use Nails or Staples for Hardwood Flooring?
Get the right flooring tools for the job.
Installing hardwood flooring is a major investment, not just in cost but in craftsmanship. Whether you’re upgrading a living room, retail space, or office, a properly installed floor adds value, durability, and lasting appeal. But before you lay the first plank, you need to decide: should you use nails or staples?
The answer starts with the right flooring tools—specifically, a flooring nailer or a flooring stapler. Both are reliable options, but they function differently and perform better in different scenarios. Let’s break it down.
Flooring Nailers vs. Flooring Staplers
If you’re installing solid hardwood over a wood subfloor (plywood or OSB), you’ll likely be choosing between cleat nails and flooring staples as opposed to other installation methods, such as glue. These fasteners are driven through the tongue of each board at a 45-degree angle, securing the plank without showing on the surface. The tool you use determines the fastener—and vice versa.
Flooring Nailers: Built for Flexibility
Best for: Thicker or harder hardwoods
Flooring nailers fire cleat nails, which are designed to accommodate natural wood movement caused by changes in humidity. The ridged shank allows the board to expand and contract without cracking or creaking. Nails are also much less likely to split the tongue of the board during installation.
Most flooring nailers are mallet-actuated—just line it up on the board’s tongue and strike the plunger with a mallet. Many models allow you to work from a standing position, which eases the strain on your knees and back during long installs.
Example: The SENCO SHF200 Flooring Nailer delivers consistent performance in dense woods like hickory. It’s a durable, well-balanced tool that minimizes tongue damage and works with a wide range of hardwood species.
Flooring Staplers: Speed and Grip
Best for: Softer woods, thinner boards, and faster installs
Flooring staplers fire flooring staples, which grip the tongue firmly with wide, two-pronged fasteners. These tools are typically trigger-actuated and resemble a traditional pneumatic nail gun—making them easy to operate, especially for beginners.
They’re faster to use than nailers and more forgiving on learning curves. The trade-off? You’ll often be working from your knees, which can be tough on the body during large-scale jobs. Additionally, the two points on a staple, compared to one on a nail, can make hardwood boards more prone to splitting when the fastener is driven, though a quality tool and well-crafted staples will prevent this.
Example: The SENCO SLS20XP-L Flooring Stapler is lightweight, fast, and ideal for softwoods like pine or spruce, as well as laminate flooring.
Get to Know the Fasteners: Cleat Nails vs. Flooring Staples
Cleat Nails (16-gauge L-head)
- Designed specifically for hardwood flooring
- Feature a ribbed shank for holding power and flexibility
- The L-head design improves anchoring without splitting the board
- Ideal for hardwoods that expand and contract—like hickory, oak, or maple
- Great for minimizing creaks and long-term shifting
Flooring Staples (19-gauge, 3/16″ crown)
- Commonly used for engineered or softer hardwoods and laminate
- Two-pronged, medium wire staples grip the board tightly
- 19-gauge thickness offers strength without splitting thin materials
- Best for applications where speed and cost efficiency matter
- Hold the flooring firmly in place but may limit natural wood movement
Both types of fasteners are engineered for reliable performance—but they behave differently once installed. Cleat nails flex with the wood, helping to prevent squeaks. Staples hold fast, which is ideal in many cases but can lead to tension if the flooring contracts or expands based on humidity.
What Else Should You Consider?
- Wood Type: Harder woods like walnut or cherry benefit from cleat nails. Softer woods like pine are often better suited for staples.
- Project Size: Nailers are easier on your body for big jobs. Staplers can speed things up when time is tight.
- Manufacturer Recommendations: Always check if your flooring brand specifies a certain fastener or tool type—especially for engineered hardwood.
Why Choose Hardwood Over Vinyl?
It’s not just about looks—hardwood flooring outperforms vinyl in several key areas:
- Durability: Solid hardwood can be sanded and refinished multiple times. Vinyl? Once it’s damaged, it’s done.
- Resale Value: Homes with hardwood floors often sell faster and for more money.
- Sustainability: Hardwood is a natural, renewable resource—unlike synthetic vinyl.
- Aesthetics: Hardwood offers depth, warmth, and character that vinyl just can’t replicate.
When paired with the right flooring tools, a hardwood floor becomes more than just a surface—it’s a long-term investment in quality.
Bottom Line: Choose What Works Best for You
There’s no universal right answer between a flooring nailer and a flooring stapler—just the right tool for your wood type, schedule, and even the climate you’re in. Both cleat nails and flooring staples are up to the task. The key is choosing the right setup that delivers comfort, consistency, and clean results.
Whether you’re a seasoned pro or taking on your first flooring project, SENCO has the tools to help you get it right the first time. From nailers to staplers, compressors to fasteners, you’ll find everything you need to build a floor that lasts.
Related Posts
